Thank you to everyone who participated and thank you once more Kiwi for being an excellent host. It is very gratifying to promote this scale again. I had some notes ready but hadn't posted them before because I feared they'd influence the vote, so here they are.
dalamace’s RED-ARC: Very attractive, shapely, looks the part. Feels modern in a '90s kind of way but it fits the late '80s. The complex turret geometry gives it a lot of character. Wonder how hard it is for the driver to get out through his hatch. The imperfectly applied camo is a great touch. My biggest design concern is that it says the crew sits below the turret ring so the turret can be armoured only against 30mm fire, but the blocky turret suggests extensive armour arrays and the cupolas mean the crew’s stations are well within the turret.
Jxyzer’s SM-1 Barako LST: First time in a challenge if I’m not mistaken. The camouflage has a good colour selection, the application reveals too much of a round brush but works if you don’t look too closely. The drawing’s definition is a bit hit or miss, the big weld line on the turret cheek is jarring and there’s nothing defining how the gunner’s sight is placed. The commander has no way of looking forward while buttoned up with that splash shield there and the vision blocks being so low. The machinegun is too low to allow the commander decent elevation. The design works conceptually but as drawn seems a bit bland. Brave effort that has lots of areas in which to improve.
Hood’s FV4301 Champion: Absolutely loved this the moment I saw it. Really tempted to just steal it for my own purposes. Conceptually I have an issue with it not having a dedicated loader, considering its not really that small of a tank. I understand Charioteer did this IRL, but still I wonder if an autoloader of some kind couldn’t have been adopted, a carousel perhaps. Visually, I can only lament that its not adorned with a BAOR or Berlin Brigade camo and some markings, though british tanks were notorious for being a bit bare and drab.
Wolftheriot’s CLR-80: It looks weird but I can’t find a serious flaw with it! Some things like the wheel hub shading could be more delicate, and the markings could use less saturated colours, but overall its pretty damn good.
Mauser’s Moloch: A safe and logical design, fits the challenge perfectly. The drawing is good and the camouflage interesting though its missing a bit of a spark to it. Maybe adding stowage would help with it. I graded it well.
Kiwi Imperialist’s Dongmu-ho: Chibi Type 59 worthy of a Hasegawa Egg kit. Works fine as a concept, it being spun as an assault gun is believable but I wouldn’t have needed that much to find this realistic when its close to Type 62 anyways. The centerpiece of the drawing is the big bobble turret, whose purposeful highlighting shows its shape well. The tank has enough details and stowage to not look busy, but I wonder if it would’ve looked even better if it was busier. Solid entry with good marks.
El_snow’s AL-5 Skirmisher: Love this little goober, looks like what a light tank should look. The stowage and camo are very good. I wonder if the holes on the wheels should be black or let light through. Would like to see some stats on this just for peace of mind.
Rowdy36’s Bardick AS1: Very handsome thing, this one, mini Chalbrams got the best of both parents. Once more the markings have fully saturated colours and could be a bit greyer. The sand skirts are too gradienty and look jpeg’d. The vision blocks could use a black outline though I understand there’s very little space to allow for this (if only we had moved on to spergscale instead!). One thing that bothers me is that even applying every weight saving method known to humankind I don’t think this boy could go below 35 tonnes at combat load. Likewise those massive turret cheeks don’t look like they’re just to stop 30mm APFSDS, they look like they’ll stop a 3BM-25 dead on its track, nevermind any kind of PG-7 round. I only discounted one point from the design criterion though because it just looks so well put together!
_Zustt_’s NEDS/20.138: An interesting and quirky design that gains points for this, but looks like it lack a bit of gun depression? Should behave like a dune buggy with so much power. The markings are conservative but effective, but camo would’ve livened it up a lot. Still, good effort.
Charguizard’s A.89 Granchio: I forgor to make the roadwheels on the other side visible
Wish I could show the sketches and notes too because I put a lot of effort into those, which justify the tank’s final appearance. Originally I was going to draw it rigged for a parachute drop, strapped on a pallet, but I got distracted by other projects and ran out of time. Edit with stat block soon maybe.
MattewEx’s Lowe: A conservative design, but in that lies the safety of knowing it’d work. Would like to see some stats, neither Marder nor Leopard 1 basis are exactly within the margins of the challenge weight limit, but this tank could be, who knows. Still, well drawn, with attractive angles, maybe a bit muted, the sprocket is very basic. The stowage and tools are pretty good. A nice basic camouflage scheme and a cupola machinegun would turn this into a looker.
MrJetMan’s C1A Corazziere: Very eye catching, well drawn, with considerable stowage and details and a nice basic camouflage, only the vision block colour lets it down. Designwise its a known concept and its got all the equipment to make it work, so I checked it as very believable. Solid entry.