Shipbucket

hahahahaha
you are joking, right?
you fire one anti-ship missile and you expect the AEGIS system to find it difficult?
bloody hell, AEGIS is an anti-saturation system. you have to fire more missiles at the same time at it then it can counter. if you fire just one missile, the missile is being shot down moments after it is detected. whatever the missile type.

Well, AEGIS *could* be saturated since it uses 2 to 4 SPG-62 directors for terminal phase guidance. But for Tacticos/APAR/SMART-L, with the capability to guide 16 missiles in terminal phase, is a different story.

And why does anybody even listen to Karlo Kopp? The man is regarded as a joke by anyone who actually works in the defence establishment.

Curiously, we have not seen any public proposals to add further illuminator/engagement radars (eg SPG-60 series) on either the FFGs or the ANZACs. Adding an additional pair to either class would double the ships' capacity to handle a saturation attack, and also increase the likelihood of successfully killing a 2 round Alfa salvo. However, it would also weaken the case for a SPY-1 Aegis system, and bigger ships to carry it, which perhaps explains its lack of attractiveness.

The big question which must be asked is a simple one. At what point does the massive expediture on SAMs and radars required to get any measure of survivability from a surface warship outweigh the operational usefulness of the vessel itself ? If tanker supported fighters, which are capable of performing many other roles, can survivably destroy opposing ASCM shooting warships and aircraft, is not air power a better investment for blue water ASuW and AAW ?

The naval lobby frequently likes to argue that air power is an adjunct and thus a supporting capability in the blue water ASuW and AAW roles. Perhaps it is time for them to finally accept that technology has overtaken the small surface warship, and that without prohibitive investments in AAW/SAM capabilities, it is best used as a niche asset for specialised roles such as ASW, patrol, escort and fire support in lower threat level environments.